Skip to content
Research Agent Skillsby Kalaris Labs
Install
Research Writingv1.0OriginalMIT

cover-letter-to-editor

Write journal submission cover letters, presubmission inquiries, transfer requests, and reviewer suggestion or exclusion lists that help a manuscript get past editorial triage. Use when submitting a paper to a journal, pitching a manuscript to an editor (presubmission enquiry), transferring after rejection, explaining a resubmission or appeal, or preparing the editor-facing parts of a submission such as the significance pitch, suggested reviewers and conflicts. Not for job or fellowship application letters.

Install this skill

Works with Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, Gemini CLI, GitHub Copilot, OpenCode, and 70+ other harnesses.

skills.sh CLI (Recommended)
npx skills add KalarisLabs/research-agent-skills --skill cover-letter-to-editor
uvx (Python tool runner)
uvx research-agent-skills install cover-letter-to-editor

Documentation & Instructions

Cover Letters and Editor Communications

At selective journals an editor decides in minutes whether to send a paper to review. The cover letter is your only direct pitch: why this journal's readers need this result now. It does not summarize the abstract.

Before writing

Collect: the journal's scope/aims statement and article type; the main finding in one sentence with its key number; 1-3 recent papers in this journal your work builds on or challenges; required declarations (see the journal's guide).

Structure (one page)

  1. Opening: manuscript title, article type, journal. One sentence.
  2. The finding and why it matters, 2-4 sentences: the problem, what you found (with the key number), and what it changes. Written for a smart non-specialist editor.
  3. Why this journal: connect to the journal's readership and scope, and cite recent papers it published if you extend or overturn them. Avoid flattery.
  4. What is new vs. prior work: one or two sentences, concrete (larger cohort, first causal evidence, 10× faster, new mechanism).
  5. Declarations the journal asks for: not under consideration elsewhere, all authors approved, preprint server and DOI if posted, competing interests, related manuscripts under review, data availability.
  6. Reviewers: suggested reviewers (name, institution, email, expertise, no conflicts: not recent co-authors or same institution). Opposed reviewers with a brief, professional reason.
  7. Sign-off by the corresponding author with contact details.

Template

Dear Dr. [Editor surname],

We submit our manuscript "[Title]" for consideration as a [Article type] in [Journal].

[Problem in one sentence]. Here we show that [main finding with key number], using [approach
and scale]. This [resolves / overturns / enables] [specific consequence].

This work will interest [Journal]'s readers in [fields] because [reason]. It builds on
[Author et al., Journal, Year], which [what they showed], by [what you add].

The manuscript has not been published and is not under consideration elsewhere. All authors
approved the submission. A preprint is available at [server, DOI]. The authors declare [no
competing interests / the interests listed in the manuscript].

Suggested reviewers: [Name, Institution, email: expertise]. [...]
We request that [Name] not review this manuscript due to [brief professional reason].

Sincerely,
[Name, affiliation, email, ORCID]

Variants

  • Presubmission inquiry (Nature Portfolio, PLOS Biology, Cell Press and others): abstract + ~200-word pitch focused on significance. The editor answers "would consider" or "not suitable".
  • Transfer after rejection: mention the previous journal and decision. If reviews transfer, summarize how you addressed them.
  • Resubmission after reject-and-resubmit: list the main changes and link to the full response to reviewers (see rebuttal-and-response-to-reviewers).
  • Appeal: only for clear reviewer error or misunderstanding of central points. Be factual, brief and specific, and offer additional evidence.

Don'ts

  • Don't repeat the abstract, or use hype ("groundbreaking", "paradigm-shifting").
  • Don't overclaim beyond the manuscript or bury required declarations.
  • Don't suggest reviewers with conflicts, or friends, or fabricated contacts. This is research misconduct.
  • Don't exceed one page unless the journal asks for more.

Related skills

abstract-and-title, rebuttal-and-response-to-reviewers, reproducibility-statement, journal-format skills (nature-portfolio, science-aaas, cell-press, plos, ...), venue-templates.

Trigger Prompts & Evaluation Corpus

These evaluation prompts test that the agent correctly selects cover-letter-to-editor for relevant tasks and leaves it out for near misses.

Should trigger (1)

  • should trigger

    “Write a cover letter submitting our manuscript to Science, with suggested reviewers.”

    expects One-page letter: finding with number, why this journal, declarations, conflict-free reviewers

Near misses (1)

  • near miss

    “Write a job application cover letter for a postdoc position.”

    expects Skill not used